Home Forums The Bitcoin Standard Robinhood an app that holds Bitcoin

  • Robinhood an app that holds Bitcoin

    Posted by Taye Bela Corby on October 25, 2024 at 18:32

    My Bicoin has been restricted on the Robinhood app after sending Bitcoin payment to TheBitcoinWay. I wanted to post to Saifedean and the forums to see if there are best practices as to what to do? I would prefer not to have to sell and buy back my Bitcoin. (Please excuse if this is not the proper place to post this question, and if you would provide a more appropriate place to learn from the wisdom and experience here.) Thank you!

    Taye Bela Corby replied 1 week ago 3 Members · 4 Replies
  • 4 Replies
  • Alexander Abdulkader Kheirallah

    Member
    December 3, 2024 at 19:12

    “Not your keys, not your coins,” as the saying goes. The app may owe you bitcoin, but you don’t truly own it until it’s stored in a wallet controlled by your secret key. This situation might actually be a blessing in disguise, encouraging you to ensure your wallet is set up to transfer your sats from the app’s custody to your private one. (It sounds like you’re already on this path, given your sign-up with the Bitcoin Way service.)

    If I were in your position, I’d contact the app representative to understand their reasoning behind this decision and whether they might ultimately release your funds. It’s worth noting that blockchain surveillance companies often score wallet addresses based on their “risk profile.” These scores can sometimes be inaccurate, associating addresses with suspicious entities due to interactions further down the chain of transactions. If the address you sent your bitcoin to has been flagged this way, it could be the cause of the issue.

    Explain to the app representative that you are simply paying for a completely legal service and provide evidence to support this. This might persuade them to release your bitcoin.

    If they still object, but you’re able to settle the debt they owe you via fiat currency, it might be worth doing so. You could then use the equivalent amount (minus fees) to purchase bitcoin through alternative means—either privately (no KYC) or through reputable vendors (with KYC). This time, ensure that the bitcoin is sent directly to your private wallet under your control.

    I hope this helps!

  • Taye Bela Corby

    Member
    December 11, 2024 at 18:46

    Thank you for your thoughtful response! Since then, I’ve sold all my Bitcoin from Robinhood and filed a complaint with the California Attorney General. I’ve learned there was already a class-action lawsuit against Robinhood for forcing consumers to sell their Bitcoin after deeming the recipient addresses fraudulent, which indefinitely restricted users’ ability to send their funds. Although Robinhood settled the dispute financially, the issue persists. To ensure better control and security, I’m now working with The Bitcoin Way to set up my own wallet and hold my Bitcoin independently.

    I believe that becoming more and more aware of aligning to a Bitcoin Standard I am also holding a higher accountability to push back on what is unfair.

    Thanks again!

  • Michael

    Member
    December 13, 2024 at 15:15

    So who owns Bitcoin Way? Can i buy Bitcoin with Bitcoin Way at what price?

    • Taye Bela Corby

      Member
      December 18, 2024 at 21:04

      I’m not sure who their owners are but I have happily worked with Tony and Endi. Very helpful for everything related to self-custody properly.

Log in to reply.